FCA authorised · FRN 724952 0117 325 0027Goods in transit: buy onlineQuote & buy →
Apex Insurance Brokers
Speak to a brokerGet a quote →

Aipedia: Claims management companies

AI-written complaints to the Ombudsman

CMCs can use AI to draft complaints and Ombudsman submissions, but the firm is accountable for every inaccurate fact or reference. The Ombudsman has publicly criticised AI submissions from professional representatives, and each referral now carries a case fee.

In short

The Financial Ombudsman Service has reported AI-assisted submissions from professional representatives of around 200 pages with multiple inaccuracies, and one case where 37 of 39 references were wrong. Since April 2025 CMCs pay £250 per referral after 10 free cases, with £175 back if upheld. No rule bans AI drafting, but the Consumer Duty and record-keeping rules make the firm responsible for accuracy. Where a client loses redress because of a flawed submission, PI may respond if held, but fees and fines are commonly outside cover.

Using AI in your work? Make sure your professional indemnity covers it. A specialist broker can check your wording and find cover that does.
Get a second opinion on your PIDoes PI cover AI mistakes?

How CMCs use AI to draft complaints

For a financial services CMC, the complaint letter to the firm and any later referral to the Financial Ombudsman Service are the core of the product. Generative AI makes it quick to turn a client questionnaire and a pile of lender data into a long, confident letter, to answer an investigator's initial assessment, and to cite previous decisions, rules and guidance in support. Some firms may draft much of their correspondence this way and send it out with limited human review.

What the Ombudsman has seen

The Ombudsman has put its concerns on the record. In its response to the Mills Review (2 April 2026) it said that in a small early sample up to 35% of responses to initial assessments were likely AI-assisted. It described professional representatives filing AI-assisted submissions of around 200 pages, with multiple inaccuracies, in reply to a provisional decision of 6 to 8 pages. It asked the FCA for clarity on records of AI use, routes to a human, and what happens when AI is used on both sides of a dispute.

In October 2026, as reported in the trade press, Chief Ombudsman James Dipple-Johnstone told the Financial Times that in one case 37 of 39 references in a submission were incorrect, and that CMCs and legal representatives were sending AI submissions, some "more than 200 pages", that create "unnecessary burden".

The cost of a weak referral

Since 1 April 2025 the FOS has charged professional representatives £250 for each case referred after 10 free cases a year. £175 is refunded if the complaint is upheld in the consumer's favour, so an upheld case costs a net £75. Where a representative's case is not upheld or is withdrawn, the respondent firm pays a reduced fee of £475. An AI process that refers weak or poorly argued complaints in bulk therefore costs the CMC money directly, before any regulatory or civil consequences.

The duties that apply

There is no specific rule on AI-drafted complaints; check the current CMCOB conduct rules in the FCA Handbook or with your compliance adviser.

What can go wrong

Illustrative scenario. A CMC uses a generative AI tool to respond to an investigator's view on an irresponsible lending complaint. The reply quotes decisions that do not say what is claimed and misstates the client's income from the lender's records. The ombudsman gives it little weight and the complaint fails. The client later finds that the original data supported a stronger argument the CMC never made, and alleges the firm's negligence cost them redress.

The same pattern can also produce regulatory scrutiny if it repeats across a book of cases, and reputational damage with the Ombudsman, which now looks for signs of AI-generated material.

How PI usually responds

A client's claim that negligent complaint handling lost them compensation is the kind of loss PI is designed for, so cover is usually engaged if the firm holds PI and the wording is silent on AI, subject to the policy terms. Most financial services CMCs are not required to hold PI, so some carry none. Lost FOS case fees, the cost of re-doing files, regulatory fines and refunds of the CMC's own fees are commonly not covered. See Does claims firm PI cover AI errors? and AI hallucination liability.

Practical controls

How Apex helps

Apex arranges PI for claims management companies. A broker can check whether your wording responds to complaint-handling errors produced with AI and how it treats regulatory matters. See also AI in claims management.

Sources

Frequently asked

Is it against the rules to use AI to write FOS complaints?

No rule bans it. The firm remains responsible for the accuracy of what it submits under the Consumer Duty and its general obligations, and the Ombudsman has said inaccurate AI submissions create unnecessary burden. Use AI to draft, but have a person check and own the final version.

How much does the FOS charge a CMC to refer a complaint?

Since 1 April 2025, £250 per case after 10 free cases a year. £175 is refunded if the complaint is upheld for the consumer, leaving a net £75. Poor-quality AI referrals therefore carry a direct cost.

Would PI cover a client who lost their complaint because of an AI error?

It may, if the firm holds PI, the client can show negligence caused a loss, and the wording does not exclude it. PI is not compulsory for financial services CMCs. Lost case fees and regulatory penalties are commonly outside cover.

Check your PI covers how you use AI

Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.

Start a PI quote Request a callback

Apex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.