Aipedia: Data protection consultants
Biometric data used to identify people is special category data, so advice on facial recognition or other biometric AI must find both a lawful basis and an Article 9 condition. The discrimination risk is real, and a consultant whose advice proves wrong may face a claim.
Part of: AI in Data protection consultants
In short
Clients deploy biometric AI for building access, time and attendance, identity checks, age estimation and security. Under Article 9 of the UK GDPR, biometric data processed to uniquely identify a person is special category data, which needs an Article 9(2) condition such as explicit consent or substantial public interest. The ICO publishes biometric recognition guidance and has made biometrics a strategic priority. Manjang v Uber Eats, settled with EHRC support in 2024, showed how automated facial checks can lead to a race discrimination claim. Advice that understates these risks can expose the consultant. PI usually responds to negligent advice claims, subject to the wording.
Typical requests include whether staff can clock in by face scan, whether a gym or venue can use facial recognition at the entrance, whether a platform can verify identity with a selfie match, and whether a retailer can use cameras to identify known offenders. Clients may assume that because a vendor sells the system, it must be lawful to use. The consultant's task is to test the use case, the alternatives and the safeguards, not just the vendor's paperwork.
A DPIA will almost always be needed.
Manjang v Uber Eats concerned a courier whose account was deactivated after automated facial recognition checks, and who alleged race discrimination. The EHRC supported the claim, which settled; the EHRC published its release on 26 March 2024. For advisers the point is that data protection compliance and discrimination risk cannot be separated. A system that performs less accurately for some groups, combined with an automated consequence such as deactivation, creates both a fairness issue under data protection law and an equality law claim.
Illustrative scenario: a consultant advises an employer that it can introduce facial recognition clock-in on the basis of staff consent. The advice does not address the imbalance of power, offers no alternative for staff who refuse, and does not consider error rates across different groups. Staff complain, the ICO makes enquiries and the employer withdraws the system, losing its investment. It then claims against the consultant for the wasted cost and its response costs.
Advice on whether a biometric system can lawfully be used is professional advice, and a PI policy usually responds to a negligence claim about it, subject to the wording. Losses can include sunk technology costs, so the size of a claim may be out of proportion to the fee. Where a claim includes discrimination-related losses passed back from the client, some wordings respond differently, so check how yours is framed. On fines and their insurability, see are AI regulatory fines insurable? and on algorithmic decisions more generally algorithmic decisions and PI.
Apex arranges PI for data protection consultants. A broker can review how your policy treats biometric and surveillance advice; see the data protection consultants' AI hub.
Yes, where biometric data is processed to uniquely identify a person, Article 9(1) treats it as special category data. A lawful basis and an Article 9(2) condition are both required, and a DPIA will usually be needed.
Explicit consent is one Article 9(2) condition, but consent from employees is difficult because of the imbalance of power. Advice should consider whether consent is genuinely free and offer a non-biometric alternative.
It did not reach a judgment. The courier's claim, supported by the EHRC, alleged race discrimination after automated facial recognition checks led to deactivation, and it settled, with the EHRC publishing its release on 26 March 2024.
A PI policy usually responds to negligence claims over such advice, subject to its terms. Check how the wording treats discrimination-related losses and any exclusions for surveillance or biometric work.
Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Start a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.