Aipedia: Structural and civil engineers
AI carbon tools can estimate embodied carbon quickly, but engineers must check the data and methods behind them before advising clients. Carbon figures increasingly feed marketing, funding and planning decisions, so errors can be costly.
Part of: AI in structural and civil engineering
In short
Engineers now calculate and advise on the embodied carbon of structures, often using AI-assisted calculators that pull quantities from models and match them to carbon factors. Results depend on quantity accuracy, the choice of factors, the boundary of the assessment and the assumptions behind any optimisation. Clients may quote the figures to funders, planners or the market. The Statement of Ethical Principles asks engineers to explain uncertainties and limits of evidence. PI usually responds to negligent carbon advice, subject to the wording, but guaranteed outcomes and overstated claims can fall outside cover.
Uses include automated quantity take-off from BIM models, matching materials to carbon factor databases, comparing frame options, AI suggestions for lower carbon alternatives, and drafting carbon sections of planning or sustainability reports. Many clients now ask structural engineers to set carbon targets at concept stage and track them through design. Optimisation tools, covered in our guide to generative design and optimisation, often include carbon as an objective.
Data quality is the main issue. Model quantities may omit elements, double count others or assume wrong material specifications. AI matching can pick a generic carbon factor when a product-specific one was intended, or the reverse. Assessment boundaries may differ between options, making comparisons misleading. Narrative drafted by AI can describe a design as "low carbon" or "net zero aligned" without the evidence to support it, and the client may repeat that wording publicly.
The other risk is structural. A lower carbon option may mean slimmer members, different materials or longer spans, which must still meet strength, robustness and serviceability requirements. Carbon savings should not be bought with reduced structural margins nobody noticed.
Competence is a further question. Carbon assessment involves its own methods, data sources and reporting conventions. An engineer who relies on a tool without understanding how it reaches its numbers is poorly placed to spot an error or explain uncertainty to a client.
Illustrative scenario: an engineer's AI-generated carbon report supports a developer's claim that a building's frame achieves a stated carbon reduction. A later audit finds the tool used factors for a different cement type and omitted foundations. The developer faces challenge from a funder and claims the cost of reassessment and redesign from the engineer.
PI usually responds to claims that carbon advice was given negligently, subject to the wording. Problems arise where the engineer has warranted an outcome, such as guaranteeing a carbon figure, because contractual guarantees and fitness for purpose obligations are commonly limited or excluded. Statements that overstate environmental performance can also lead to disputes that sit uneasily with PI. Where carbon advice is outside the professional business described in your policy, cover may be uncertain, so check that the description reflects the services you actually provide. Our guide to net zero advisory exposure for engineers looks at this in detail, and the structural engineers PI guide covers the wider policy.
Related: AI-drafted reports and whether PI covers AI design errors. Back to AI in structural and civil engineering.
Apex arranges PI for engineers giving carbon and net zero advice. A broker reviews your cover, appointment terms on carbon targets, and how your policy treats AI-assisted carbon assessments.
Use it as a starting point. Check quantities, carbon factors and the assessment boundary before advising, and explain the uncertainties. Principle 4 of the Statement of Ethical Principles asks engineers to be clear about the limits of their evidence.
Your report should state the method, boundary and limitations clearly, and you should avoid language that overstates performance. If you know figures will be used publicly, agree how they will be presented and check the wording.
Usually not in full. PI responds to negligent advice, but guarantees and fitness for purpose obligations are commonly excluded or limited. Advise on targets rather than guaranteeing them, and check your appointment and policy wording.
It can be, but it is a distinct skill. IStructE Code of Conduct Article 5 requires engineers to undertake only tasks they are competent for, so training and experience in carbon assessment matter as much as access to a tool.
Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Start a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.