FCA authorised · FRN 724952 0117 325 0027Goods in transit: buy onlineQuote & buy →
Apex Insurance Brokers
Speak to a brokerGet a quote →

Aipedia: Fire risk assessors

Generic AI templates and copy-paste FRAs

A fire risk assessment built from a generic template or AI-filled text may not be suitable and sufficient, because the law requires an assessment of the specific premises. When the fire and rescue authority finds failings, the client faces enforcement and often looks to the assessor.

In short

Templates have always been part of fire risk assessment, and AI makes them faster to fill. The problem comes when standard text replaces observation: escape routes described for a building that does not have them, management arrangements copied from another client, or a significant finding hidden in boilerplate. Article 9 requires a suitable and sufficient assessment of the actual premises. Fire and rescue authorities enforce against the responsible person, who keeps legal responsibility, but a client facing an enforcement notice will often claim the cost of putting things right from the assessor whose report missed the problem.

Using AI in your work? Make sure your professional indemnity covers it. A specialist broker can check your wording and find cover that does.
Get a second opinion on your PIDoes PI cover AI mistakes?

How templates and AI fill-in are used

Most assessment software is built around a template: section headings, question sets and a library of standard observations and recommendations. AI adds a further layer. It can pick likely answers based on the building type, generate narrative from a few keywords, or reuse text from the last similar job. For a block of flats or a small office, much of the template content will be broadly right, which is exactly why it is easy to accept without challenge.

The Hackitt review described many FRAs as "little more than a 'tick box' exercise", a criticism quoted by MHCLG in its 2026 consultation. Template-heavy, AI-filled reports are at risk of being seen in the same light.

The issue is not the template itself but what happens to observation. When the software proposes an answer, the assessor's job quietly changes from looking and recording to accepting or rejecting. Over a long day, accepting wins. The result is a report that is consistent across clients, which is helpful, but also consistently blind to whatever makes each building different: a change of use, an unusual layout, a vulnerable occupant group or a management weakness.

The duties that apply

Under Article 9 the responsible person must make a "suitable and sufficient assessment of the risks" and record the significant findings, including groups especially at risk. Article 25 makes fire and rescue authorities the enforcers, and they act against responsible persons. NFCC's guidance for duty holders tells clients to get quotes on a defined scope, check the assessor's experience with their premises type and seek references, including whether the authority later found problems. A generic report is precisely what a reference check is designed to expose. The basics are covered in our fire safety risk assessment explainer.

What can go wrong

Generic content tends to fail in recognisable ways:

Illustrative scenario: a fire and rescue authority audits a small hotel and finds the FRA describes a fire alarm system and protected staircase that do not match the building. It issues an enforcement notice requiring works and a new assessment. The hotel owner pays for the works and the new assessment, then claims those costs and the disruption from the original assessor, arguing the report was not specific to the premises.

How PI usually responds

A claim that a report was negligent because it was generic is a straightforward professional negligence allegation, which PI is usually designed to meet, subject to the terms. The harder questions are about what is recoverable: the cost of a replacement assessment and remedial works the client would have needed anyway may be disputed as loss. Fines or penalties imposed on the client are generally not something the assessor's PI would pay directly, and fines are commonly uninsurable. Check also whether your wording has fire safety restrictions. See PI for fire risk assessors and fire safety PI exposure.

Practical controls

Templates can stay, as long as they support observation rather than replace it. Sensible controls include:

Related guides cover AI report writing, high-volume portfolio work and the fire risk assessment Aipedia hub.

How Apex helps

Apex arranges PI for fire risk assessors. A broker can check whether your cover has fire safety restrictions and how it would treat a claim that a report was generic.

Sources

Frequently asked

Is it wrong to use a template for a fire risk assessment?

No. Templates help consistency. The risk is when template or AI-generated text replaces what was actually observed, so the assessment no longer reflects the premises. The Article 9 test is whether the assessment is suitable and sufficient for that building.

Can the fire service take action against the assessor?

Fire and rescue authorities enforce against the responsible person, not the assessor. The assessor's exposure is usually a civil claim by the client, for example for the cost of a new assessment or works, if the original report was negligent.

How would a client show that an FRA was generic?

Usually by comparing it with the building. Descriptions of features that do not exist, room names from another property or management arrangements the client never had are strong evidence. An enforcing authority audit or a new assessor's report often brings these mismatches to light.

Would PI pay the cost of redoing a generic FRA?

It depends on the wording and the facts. A claim for loss caused by a negligent assessment may be covered, but costs the client would have incurred anyway, and fines, are commonly disputed or excluded. A broker can explain how your policy approaches this.

Check your PI covers how you use AI

Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.

Start a PI quote Request a callback

Apex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.