Aipedia: Insurance brokers
Usually, a broker's PI policy will treat an error made with AI like any other error in the conduct of the business, subject to the wording. The detail matters because MIPRU 3.2 sets minimum terms, and an insurer could add AI-specific exclusions or conditions.
Part of: AI in insurance brokers
In short
Broker PI must meet MIPRU 3.2.4R, including cover for the conduct of the firm, its employees and appointed representatives, defence costs and Ombudsman awards. Most broker E&O wordings do not mention AI, so AI-caused errors are typically covered as ordinary professional errors: this is often called silent AI. Some wordings may add AI exclusions, conditions or definitions. The FCA has made no statement on AI and broker PI. Brokers should check their wording, understand how claims involving outsourced AI vendors are treated and describe their AI use accurately at renewal.
PI is compulsory for insurance intermediaries under MIPRU 3.2.1R. MIPRU 3.2.4R requires the policy to cover the conduct of the firm, its employees and its appointed representatives, to meet the minimum limits, to apply a permitted excess, to include legal defence costs, to provide continuous cover from the date of Part 4A permission and to cover Ombudsman awards. The limits under MIPRU 3.2.7R are EUR 1,300,380 per single claim and, in aggregate, the higher of EUR 1,924,560 or 10% of annual income, capped at £30 million. See own PI for insurance brokers under MIPRU 3 for the full picture.
MIPRU 3.2.11R and 3.2.12R cap the excess at the higher of £2,500 or 1.5% of income for firms not holding client money, and the higher of £5,000 or 3% for firms that do. A larger excess requires additional capital under MIPRU 3.2.14R.
Most broker E&O wordings were written before generative AI and simply cover negligent acts, errors or omissions in the conduct of the insurance distribution business. They neither include nor exclude AI. In that position, often called silent AI, an error made with an AI tool will commonly be treated like any other error, because the cover turns on the professional activity rather than the tool.
Insurers may add AI-specific terms, such as exclusions for losses caused by AI outputs, conditions requiring human review, or definitions that limit cover for certain AI uses. How these interact with the MIPRU 3.2.4R minimum terms is a question for the specific wording. The AI exclusions and clauses guide explains the common types, and affirmative AI cover versus silent AI covers the alternative.
Much broker AI is supplied by platforms, software houses and insurers. When a vendor's tool causes an error, the client usually claims against the broker, because the broker owes the duty of care and SYSC 8.1.6R keeps it responsible for outsourced functions. The broker's PI would typically respond to the client's claim, subject to the wording. The PI insurer may then seek to recover from the vendor through subrogation, which depends on the vendor contract. Contract terms that limit the vendor's liability, or waive the broker's rights, can affect that recovery and should be checked.
Illustrative: a broker's renewal proposal answers "no" to a question about automated advice tools, because the person completing it thinks of AI as experimental. In fact the firm uses an AI fact-find on its retail website. A claim arises from that journey. The insurer argues the risk was not fairly presented and seeks a remedy under the Insurance Act 2015. The broker faces the client's claim without the full cover it expected.
Accurate disclosure is part of your own fair presentation. See PI renewal advice for insurance brokers, FCA AI guidance explained, AI and client data confidentiality and the insurance broking AI hub.
Apex arranges PI for insurance brokers. A broker can review your wording for AI exclusions or conditions, check it still meets MIPRU 3.2.4R and help you present your AI use accurately at renewal.
Usually, if the wording is silent on AI, an error made using AI will be treated like any other error in the conduct of the business. If the policy includes AI exclusions or conditions, the answer depends on those terms. Check your wording.
MIPRU 3.2.4R sets minimum terms, including cover for the conduct of the firm and its employees. How a specific AI exclusion interacts with those requirements depends on its drafting, so any AI exclusion in a broker policy deserves careful review.
No FCA statement on AI and broker PI has been found. The FCA's AI publications focus on Consumer Duty, SM&CR and outsourcing, so the PI position depends on the policy wording and general insurance law.
The client's claim will usually be against the broker, and the broker's PI would typically respond, subject to the wording. The insurer may then try to recover from the vendor, depending on the vendor contract and any liability caps or waivers.
Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Start a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.