Aipedia: IT consultants and developers
If you recommend an AI tool that later fails, leaks data or breaches the law, the client may claim your advice was negligent. Consultants are paid for judgement, so the quality and record of your due diligence is what a claim will test.
Part of: AI in IT consultants and developers
In short
Clients now ask IT consultants which AI platforms, assistants and vendors to adopt. A recommendation that turns out badly, because the tool retains data it should not, cannot meet the client's security needs, or is unsuitable for a regulated use, can lead to a negligent advice claim. BCS clauses 2.1, 2.4 and 3.2 apply, the AI Cyber Security Code highlights supply chain security, and public sector buyers have PPN 017 expectations on AI transparency and data use. Technology PI usually responds to negligent advice claims, subject to the wording, but advice outside your declared services may be a problem.
Selection work ranges from informal suggestions in a support call to formal option appraisals. Consultants compare generative AI assistants for staff, AI features in existing business software, specialist tools for document review or customer service, and model providers for in-house development. Clients often lack the expertise to judge the claims vendors make, so they rely heavily on the consultant's view of security, data handling, suitability and cost.
The BCS Code of Conduct requires members to take on work only within their competence (2.1), know and comply with relevant legislation (2.4) and avoid conflicts (3.2). Conflicts are a live issue where consultants are resellers or receive referral fees from AI vendors; the client should know.
The AI Cyber Security Code of Practice treats supply chain security as a principle in its own right (principle 7), so a reasonable recommendation should consider how the vendor secures its models, data and components. For public sector clients, PPN 017 allows buyers to ask suppliers to declare AI use and to bar the use of buyer data to train AI without written approval, and the AI Playbook for the UK Government sets 10 principles for civil servants using AI. A tool that cannot meet those expectations may be unsuitable for a public body however good it is technically.
Illustrative scenario: a consultant recommends a generative AI note-taking tool to a small healthcare clinic, focusing on price and ease of use. The default settings send recordings to servers outside the UK and allow the vendor to use content to improve its models. The clinic only discovers this after a patient complaint. It has to stop using the tool, review its data protection position and inform affected patients, and it claims its costs from the consultant, arguing that basic due diligence would have revealed the problem.
Other claims arise where a recommended tool cannot integrate as promised, or where its outputs are unreliable for the client's regulated use, for example in decisions about people covered by the automated decision-making rules.
Technology PI commonly covers claims alleging negligent advice, provided the advice falls within the professional services described in your policy. If you mainly build software and give selection advice only occasionally, check that consultancy is included. Commission or reseller arrangements may raise questions about whether the loss arose from professional advice or from a sale, which some wordings treat differently. Where you sell or build AI yourself, wider AI insurance considerations may apply, and PI for AI consultants explains the cover in more detail.
Put your recommendation, its assumptions and its limits in writing, and suggest the client take its own legal advice where regulated data or decisions are involved. See LLM integrations and data leaks and public sector consultancy PI terms.
Apex arranges PI for IT consultants who advise on AI. A broker reviews whether your declared services cover selection advice and how your policy treats AI-related advice claims. See the IT consultants AI hub and AI clauses in IT contracts.
Yes, if the client can show your advice fell below the standard of a reasonably competent consultant and caused its loss. A tool failing does not prove negligence on its own; documented due diligence, stated assumptions and clear limits on your advice help.
Under PPN 017, public buyers may ask suppliers to declare AI used in bids and service delivery, verify AI-assisted content, and bar the use of buyer data to train AI without written approval. Tools you recommend should allow the client to meet those terms.
Only if advice is within the professional services described in your policy. Many tech PI policies cover consultancy, but check the business description on your schedule, especially if you have started advising on AI tools recently.
Yes. BCS clause 3.2 requires members to avoid conflicts, and undisclosed commission can undermine a defence if a client later says your recommendation was not independent. Disclose any reseller or referral arrangement in writing.
Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Start a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.