FCA authorised · FRN 724952 0117 325 0027Goods in transit: buy onlineQuote & buy →
Apex Insurance Brokers
Speak to a brokerGet a quote →

Aipedia: Planning consultants

AI in appeal statements and proofs of evidence

You can use AI to help prepare a statement of case or proof of evidence, but the use must be declared to the Planning Inspectorate and every citation must be real. A proof is expert evidence, so an AI error damages credibility and can bring a costs application.

In short

Appeal documents are where the Planning Inspectorate AI guidance bites hardest. Drafting, substantial rewriting, summaries and analysis by AI must be declared, with paragraph references, a description of checks and confirmation of responsibility for accuracy. Each expert declares for their own proof. In June 2025 the Divisional Court in Ayinde v Haringey warned about fake AI-generated citations, and a planning witness who cites an appeal decision that does not exist faces the same problem. Improper AI use may be unreasonable behaviour leading to a costs award.

Using AI in your work? Make sure your professional indemnity covers it. A specialist broker can check your wording and find cover that does.
Get a second opinion on your PIDoes PI cover AI mistakes?

How AI is used in appeal documents

Consultants may use AI assistants to structure statements of case, summarise the officer's report and reasons for refusal, draft rebuttals, and produce first drafts of proofs from case notes. Some use AI to compile lists of appeal decisions or court cases on a point, such as the weight to give an emerging plan.

The output often reads well and cites authority confidently. The difficulty is that generative AI can produce appeal references, quotations from inspectors and case names that do not exist, and an inquiry is exactly where they will be checked. Cross-examination tests the witness's own understanding, so a proof the witness cannot explain line by line is a liability even where every reference is correct. Written representations appeals carry the same risk in a quieter form: the inspector reads the documents closely and can ask questions about any of them. For research practice see AI research of policy and appeal decisions; the AI in planning consultancy overview gives the wider picture.

The duties that apply

The PINS declaration guide explains wording and exemptions.

What can go wrong

Illustrative scenario. A planning witness's proof cites three appeal decisions supporting a lower weight for a draft policy. The decisions were suggested by an AI assistant and not checked. The council's advocate cannot find them and raises it at the inquiry. The inspector asks for clarification of AI use under the guidance. The witness's credibility is damaged, the appellant loses, and the council applies for costs on the basis of unreasonable behaviour. The client then questions the consultant's fees and the costs.

Less dramatic failures include proofs that misstate the reasons for refusal, AI summaries of third-party evidence that omit a key point, and undeclared AI drafting discovered after a clarification request.

How PI usually responds

A client claim for a lost appeal, wasted fees or a costs order is usually a civil liability claim that PI may respond to, depending on the wording. Points to watch:

Apex's planning consultants PI guide covers limits and notification.

Practical controls

How Apex helps

Apex arranges PI for planning consultants who give evidence at appeals, and a broker can review how expert work and costs exposure are covered. See also expert witness insurance.

Sources

Frequently asked

Does a proof of evidence need an AI declaration?

Yes, if AI was used to draft or substantially rewrite it, or to produce a summary or analysis within it. The declaration can go in the proof itself or a covering letter. It should give paragraph references, describe the checks made and confirm the witness takes responsibility for accuracy.

What did the court say in Ayinde v Haringey?

The Divisional Court in [2025] EWHC 1383 (Admin), decided on 6 June 2025, gave the leading England and Wales warning about citing AI-fabricated authorities. Planning witnesses relying on appeal decisions or cases should treat it as a clear signal that every reference must be verified.

What if the inspector asks about AI use?

The guidance allows inspectors to ask for clarification. Answer accurately, explain what AI was used for and what was checked, and correct any errors. Tell your PI insurer if the issue could lead to a costs application or a client claim.

Can AI help with rebuttal proofs under time pressure?

It can help organise points and summarise the other side's evidence, but rebuttals are often prepared quickly, which is when unchecked errors slip through. Any summary of another party's proof should be checked against the original, and AI use should be declared in the rebuttal as in the main proof.

Check your PI covers how you use AI

Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.

Start a PI quote Request a callback

Apex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.