Aipedia: Quantity surveyors
Quantity surveyors can use AI to identify and apportion plant and machinery expenditure for capital allowances, but the analysis must be checked before it reaches a tax return. Errors either invite an HMRC challenge or leave allowances unclaimed, and both can lead to a PI claim.
Part of: AI in quantity surveying
In short
Capital allowances work combines cost analysis with tax rules. AI tools can read cost reports, contract sums and fixed asset registers and suggest which items qualify as plant and machinery and how to apportion costs. The risks are overclaims that HMRC challenges, underclaims a rival adviser later spots, and confusion over whether the QS or the tax adviser is responsible. Under the RICS AI standard, a named surveyor must record whether outputs are reliable (4.2). PI usually responds to negligent analysis, subject to the terms, but QSs should check the work is within their declared business.
On a new build, refurbishment or property acquisition, a QS can identify the parts of the expenditure that may qualify as plant and machinery, then apportion costs such as preliminaries and fees across qualifying and non-qualifying items. The result goes to the client's tax adviser for the return.
AI tools now read cost plans, final accounts, bills of quantities and fixed asset registers, classify items and suggest apportionments. For property acquisitions, they can help reconstruct historic costs where records are incomplete. The speed is attractive on large portfolios, but classification rules are detailed and AI is prone to treating similar-sounding items alike.
The main duties that apply are:
Common ways this goes wrong include:
Illustrative: a QS uses an AI tool to analyse the cost of a large commercial fit-out. The tool classifies a range of building fabric items as plant. The client's tax adviser files the claim on the QS's figures. HMRC opens an enquiry, the claim is reduced and the client faces additional tax and interest. The client claims from both the QS and the tax adviser, who each say the other was responsible for the classification.
A claim alleging negligent capital allowances analysis is usually handled as professional negligence under the RICS Approved Minimum Wording, subject to the policy terms. Insurers may check whether capital allowances work was declared and falls within the professional business described in the policy, because it overlaps with tax advice. Where both a QS and a tax adviser are involved, each adviser's PI responds to its own part, and contribution between them is common. The tax adviser side is covered in AI in tax advice and tax adviser PI and AI errors.
Useful controls include:
Apex arranges PI for quantity surveyors, including those offering capital allowances services. A broker can check that this work is declared and covered under your business description. Related: AI in final accounts, AI and confidentiality, the QS PI guide and the QS AI hub.
Often, but not automatically. It depends on the professional business described in the policy and what you declared on the proposal. Because the work overlaps with tax advice, confirm with your broker that it is covered before relying on it.
It depends on the engagement terms and who made the decisions. If the QS classified items negligently and the tax adviser relied on that, both may face claims, and their insurers may seek contribution from each other.
Only if the supplier maintains its rules and you check them. Under the RICS AI standard, ask the supplier in writing how rules are updated (4.1) and have a named surveyor review outputs before they are relied on (4.2).
For RICS members and regulated firms, yes. Standard 4.3 requires clients to be told in writing and in advance when and why AI is used. That also gives the client a chance to object to its asset registers or cost data being uploaded.
Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Start a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.