FCA authorised · FRN 724952 0117 325 0027Goods in transit: buy onlineQuote & buy →
Apex Insurance Brokers
Speak to a brokerGet a quote →

Aipedia: Recruitment agencies

AI candidate sourcing and database building

An agency can use AI to find candidates, but it must tell people it holds their data and must not infer what it has no right to infer. Sourcing tools that quietly build databases were a key finding of the ICO's 2024 audit.

In short

AI sourcing tools search online profiles, infer skills or attributes and enrich candidate records automatically. The ICO's November 2024 audit found tools that inferred ethnicity or gender from names and kept data indefinitely to build candidate databases without candidates knowing. Agencies are often controllers for that data, so UK GDPR Article 14 requires them to tell candidates within a reasonable period, and at the latest one month, or at first contact. A complaint can lead to ICO action and a compensation claim under Article 82. PI may respond to some third-party claims, but fines and data liabilities are commonly excluded.

Using AI in your work? Make sure your professional indemnity covers it. A specialist broker can check your wording and find cover that does.
Get a second opinion on your PIDoes PI cover AI mistakes?

How agencies use AI to source candidates

Sourcing tools search public profiles, job boards and the agency's own records, then score or tag people against a brief. Some go further: they infer seniority, likely salary or willingness to move, merge records from several sources into one enriched profile, and keep refreshing them. A consultant sees a ready-made talent pool. The candidates in it may have no idea the agency holds their details, or what the tool has guessed about them.

The duties that apply

The ICO's audit of AI recruitment tools (6 November 2024) found tools that inferred ethnicity or gender from names and kept personal data indefinitely to build databases without telling candidates. Under the ICO audit findings, building candidate databases by scraping or inference without transparency is a compliance risk, and agencies are often the controller.

The ICO's Recruitment rewired report (31 March 2026) said it will scrutinise recruitment platforms as well as employers.

What can go wrong

Illustrative: an agency's sourcing tool builds a profile of a senior engineer from public posts, adds an inferred nationality and an estimated salary, and keeps it for years. The engineer receives an outreach message, asks how the agency got their details and makes a subject access request. The response shows inferred attributes the engineer never supplied, and no privacy information was ever sent. The engineer complains to the ICO and a solicitor writes claiming distress under Article 82.

A second route to trouble is the client. If the agency shares an enriched profile containing inferred attributes with a hirer, the hirer may face its own data protection exposure and look to the agency.

How PI usually responds

There is no statutory PI requirement for agencies. A recruiter's PI policy usually responds to claims arising from the professional service, subject to the wording. Pure data protection claims are a grey area: some wordings include a limited data protection extension, others exclude data liability and leave it to a cyber or data policy. Regulatory fines are commonly uninsurable or excluded. A compensation claim under Article 82 by a candidate may sit with cyber rather than PI. See GDPR and data cover within PI and GDPR fines versus civil claims.

Practical controls

How Apex helps

Apex arranges PI for recruitment agencies. A broker can check whether your policy has any data protection cover and how it sits alongside cyber. See the AI in recruitment agencies hub, telling candidates you use AI and AI job-matching algorithms.

Sources

Frequently asked

Can a recruitment agency scrape candidate profiles with AI?

Collecting data from public profiles is not automatically unlawful, but the agency needs a lawful basis, must give Article 14 privacy information within a reasonable period and at the latest one month, or at first contact, and must not keep data indefinitely. The ICO's 2024 audit criticised tools that built databases without candidates knowing.

Is the agency or the tool supplier responsible?

Agencies are often the controller for candidate data, so they carry the main duties even when a supplier runs the tool. The supplier may be a processor or a controller in its own right, depending on the contract and what it does with the data.

Will PI cover an ICO fine for AI sourcing?

Usually not. Regulatory fines are commonly excluded or uninsurable. Some PI policies include limited data protection cover for third-party claims, and a cyber policy may respond to a compensation claim, depending on the wordings.

How long can an agency keep sourced candidate profiles?

UK GDPR does not set a fixed period, but data must not be kept longer than needed for the purpose. The ICO's 2024 audit criticised tools that kept data indefinitely to build databases. Set a retention period, apply it inside the AI tool and tell candidates what it is.

Check your PI covers how you use AI

Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.

Start a PI quote Request a callback

Apex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.