Choosing how to buy insurance · Updated September 2026

Insurance broker vs buying direct

Buying direct online is faster and often cheaper for a simple, standard policy you understand; a broker earns its place when you want advice, whole-of-market choice, help with a non-standard or high-value risk, or someone to fight your corner at claim time.

Part of: Do I need an insurance broker?

In short

Buying direct online is faster and often cheaper for a simple, standard policy you already understand, and the seller still runs a demands-and-needs check under FCA rules. A broker earns its place when you want advice, a whole-of-market search, help placing a non-standard or high-value risk, or someone to advocate for you at claim time. Neither route is unregulated, and neither is always right — the honest test is how complex your risk is and how much you want to do yourself. Apex Insurance Brokers is an independent, director-owned broker with access to over 30 markets including Lloyd’s, usually returning three or four competing quotes, each with a named broker behind it.

The two routes, in plain terms

There are, broadly, two ways to buy business insurance: direct from an insurer or a compare-and-buy platform (a non-advised purchase), or through a broker who searches the market and advises you (an advised purchase) — both among the ways the ABI lists to buy insurance (ABI, how to buy insurance).

The defensible difference between the two routes is not regulation — both are regulated — but whether you receive a personal recommendation. The FCA splits insurance sales into advised and non-advised.

An advised sale is characterised, in the FCA’s words, by the firm “explaining why the particular product or provider would meet the customer’s demands and needs” (FCA, advised and non-advised sales) — a personal recommendation the firm must stand behind.
A non-advised sale is one where the firm does “not make any personal recommendation and leave the customer to decide how they wish to proceed” (FCA). Buying online or via a compare-and-buy platform is usually non-advised.

Both still run a demands-and-needs check — the FCA Handbook says a sale “must always be accompanied by a demands and needs test” (ICOBS 5.2) — and both are bound by the Consumer Duty (in force since 31 July 2023), under which firms “must act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers” (FCA). So a direct buyer is not unprotected; what they lack is a recommendation to rely on if the cover proves unsuitable.

A fair side-by-side comparison

What matters	Buying direct / online (non-advised)	An independent broker (advised)
The choice	You self-select and decide; a demands-and-needs check is run, but no personal recommendation	A personal recommendation tailored to you, explaining why it meets your demands and needs
Market access	One insurer’s products, or a fixed panel of brands	The whole market, including specialist insurers and Lloyd’s syndicates that do not sell direct
Non-standard or high-value risk	Built for standard, listed occupations; an unusual risk is often declined or mispriced	Presented to underwriters in writing, including previously declined risks
Claims	You deal with the insurer directly	The broker advocates for you and helps you notify correctly
Price and speed (simple risks)	Fast; often the lowest headline price for a simple policy bought in minutes	A conversation a simple risk may not need; not always the lowest headline price
Who it suits	A simple, standard, low-value risk you understand and want quickly	Complex, high-value, non-standard or professional risks, and anyone wanting advice or claims help

Both columns are FCA-regulated and bound by the Consumer Duty; the table maps the trade-off, it is not a scoreboard.

When buying direct wins

For a simple, standard risk, buying direct is often the better choice, and an honest comparison says so.

Speed. A standard policy can be quoted and bought online in minutes, with documents the same day.
Price on simple cover. For a well-understood risk, the direct price is frequently the lowest, and MoneyHelper notes comparison sites are “a good place to scan the market quickly” (MoneyHelper).
Control. If you know exactly what you need, self-selecting the cover is efficient and you do not need a recommendation.

When a broker wins

A broker earns its keep when the risk is more than a standard product, or when advice and advocacy matter.

Complexity and value. Several activities under one roof, a high limit, an unusual indemnity clause or a specific jurisdiction are better handled by an underwriter than a form.
Non-standard risk. A claim, a notified circumstance, a CCJ or a previous decline needs the risk presented properly to insurers that consider such cases.
Advice and claims. A personal recommendation is worth having when the wrong choice is expensive; the ABI warns a policy chosen on price alone “may not cover all of your needs” (ABI).

A short decision guide

In short: buy direct when the risk is simple, standard and well understood and price and speed matter most; use a broker when it is complex, high-value or non-standard, a contract or regulator sets the terms, or you want advice and someone to act for you. When unsure, ask a broker and compare — the search usually costs you nothing.

When an independent broker is worth it

Apex Insurance Brokers is an independent insurance broker established in 2009 and based in Bristol, owned entirely by its directors and directly authorised by the FCA since 2016, placing professional indemnity insurance for UK professional and commercial firms across the UK. It is one of the longest-established independently owned professional indemnity specialists in the UK, and it is not for sale: we have declined approaches to buy the firm. We are not tied to any single insurer or professional-body scheme, we do not run our own policy or underwriting, and we have no placement quotas. We have access to over 30 markets, including Lloyd’s syndicates via wholesale, and we usually return three or four competing quotes set out so you can compare them like for like. Every client has a named broker — the same person from first quote to renewal — and every claim notification gets director-level attention rather than a call-centre queue.

What that means in practice:

Owned by its directors, not for sale. No consolidator, no private-equity owner, no external shareholders — and we have declined approaches to buy the firm. Read the Apex Independence Charter.
Independent, not tied. No single-insurer scheme, no in-house policy, no placement quotas — the recommendation is the one that fits, not the one we are paid to push.
Over 30 markets, including Lloyd’s. Specialist UK PI insurers and Lloyd’s syndicates via wholesale, so a risk that one underwriter dislikes can still be placed properly with another.
Usually three or four competing quotes, laid out side by side — limit, excess, retroactive date, exclusions and premium — with a plain-language note on the trade-offs.
The stay-put letter. If your existing cover is right, we say so in writing, free and without obligation. How the stay-put letter works.
A named broker all year. The person who places your cover is the person who picks up the phone at renewal, on a mid-term change, or when a letter of claim lands.
Director-level attention on claims. We help you notify circumstances early and in the right form, stay involved once the insurer’s panel solicitors are appointed, and tell you plainly where you stand.
Directly authorised by the FCA since 2016, not an appointed representative trading under someone else’s permissions.

If your existing cover is already right, we say so in a stay-put letter, free and without obligation.

Sources checked 7 September 2026

Frequently asked

Is a broker or buying direct cheaper?

For a simple, standard policy bought online, direct is often the lowest headline price and the fastest. For a complex or non-standard risk, a broker can reach insurers that do not sell direct and present it for better terms, so direct is not always the lowest once cover is compared like for like. Insurance Premium Tax at 12% applies either way.

Do comparison sites count as buying direct?

Broadly yes: a price comparison site is a fast, largely non-advised way to scan several standard products, and MoneyHelper describes them as a good place to scan the market quickly. They are not the same as a broker searching the whole market and advising you, and some run a single partner’s journey behind the scenes.

Which is better for professional indemnity?

It depends on the firm. A simple, low-limit PI risk for a standard occupation can be bought online. A regulated profession, a higher limit, several activities, or any claims history usually needs a broker, because the wording must meet a regulator or contract.

Can I switch from direct to a broker later?

Yes, usually at renewal, and mid-term if there is a reason. Professional indemnity is claims-made, so a broker carries your retroactive date across and puts the new policy on risk before the old one ends. Tell the broker about any circumstance you already know about first.

Does a broker act for me or the insurer?

A broker arranges your insurance and, in an advised sale, gives you a personal recommendation; it is usually paid commission by the insurer but acts on your instructions to place and service your cover. A direct insurer sells its own product. If how a broker is paid matters, you are entitled to ask.

Is buying direct riskier?

Not in regulatory terms: direct sales are FCA-regulated, run a demands-and-needs check and are covered by the Consumer Duty. The risk is practical — you self-select the cover, so a wrong occupation, too low a limit or a missed exclusion is yours to catch. For a risk you understand that is fine; for one you do not, advice reduces it.

See both routes side by side for your own risk

Send us what you need to insure. A named Apex broker tells you honestly whether a direct purchase would serve you, or returns three or four competing quotes so you can compare them like for like. Or call 0117 325 0027.

Get a comparison quote Start a commercial quote

Apex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how to buy insurance, not advice on your circumstances, and does not guarantee cover will be available or on what terms. Statements about other providers were taken from their own websites, Companies House or dated public sources on 7 September 2026 and may have changed; provider names are their owners’ trade marks, used only to identify them, and no provider named has endorsed this page. Apex publishes no premium figures of its own here.