Insurance explained
Professional indemnity insurance for a charity is cover for claims that advice, information, training or a professional service the charity provided was negligent and caused someone a loss. Small charities often need it because a funder, council or NHS contract asks for it, even where no law requires it.
Part of: Professional indemnity insurance
In short
A small charity usually needs professional indemnity (PI) insurance if it gives advice, counselling, training or other professional services, or if a funder or commissioning contract requires it. PI protects the charity against claims that its service was negligent. It is different from trustee indemnity insurance, which protects trustees personally, and from public liability, which covers injury and property damage. Charity Commission guidance in CC49 says a charity should consider insurance where it could be liable for negligent advice or services, and notes that, as is common, PI may only cover claims instituted during the period of cover.
Professional indemnity insurance responds when someone says the charity's advice or service fell below a reasonable standard and caused them a financial loss, or in some services distress or injury. It usually pays compensation and legal costs, subject to the policy terms. It is the same cover a consultancy or accountant would buy; see our professional indemnity insurance page for the general picture.
The Charity Commission guidance on charities and insurance (CC49) says that where a charity provides professional advice or services, "the charity may be liable if this is provided negligently", and that it "should consider insurance against claims that the charity is legally liable for loss". Typical triggers for a small charity include:
There is no general legal rule that every charity must buy PI. Employers' liability is compulsory if the charity employs staff, as CC49 notes. Our charity insurance guide covers the wider programme.
| Cover | Who it protects | Typical claim |
|---|---|---|
| Professional indemnity | The charity, and usually staff and volunteers acting for it | A client says benefits advice was wrong and they lost money |
| Trustee indemnity insurance | Trustees personally | A claim that trustees breached their duties in running the charity |
| Public liability | The charity | A visitor trips at an event and is injured |
Trustee indemnity insurance, often sold as part of a directors' and officers' or management liability policy, covers decisions made by the board. It does not normally respond to a complaint about the quality of a service the charity delivered. Our pages on trustee indemnity and PI for charities, charity trustee PI vs trustee indemnity and D&O for charities explain the split. For injury risks, see public liability insurance.
CC49 treats trustee indemnity insurance as a personal benefit to trustees, so the charity needs authority to pay for it. Many governing documents give that authority. Where they do not, section 189 of the Charities Act 2011 gives a general power, provided the trustees decide that "it is in the best interests of the charity" to buy it. The guidance adds that the cost should be reasonable. The Act requires the policy to exclude criminal fines, regulatory penalties, the costs of defending criminal proceedings ending in conviction for fraud, dishonesty or wilful or reckless misconduct, and liability to the charity for conduct a trustee knew, or must reasonably be assumed to have known, was not in the charity's interests, or where the trustee did not care whether it was.
PI that protects the charity itself is different. It is a decision trustees make in the charity's interests, like buildings or public liability cover, rather than a personal benefit.
The Commission's guidance The essential trustee (CC3) says trustees have "a duty to avoid exposing your charity to undue risk" and must "use reasonable care and skill", taking advice when necessary. It says it is "extremely rare, but not impossible" for trustees to be held personally liable, and suggests trustees "consider whether the charity needs additional insurance or needs to become incorporated".
CC3 also notes that in an unincorporated charity the trustees sign contracts personally. For a small unincorporated charity delivering a funded advice contract, a negligence claim and a contractual dispute can land close to the trustees themselves, which is one reason PI and the charity's legal structure are worth reviewing together.
Illustrative example: a volunteer-run advice centre. Volunteers help people complete benefit claims. A client misses out on an award after a form is completed wrongly and claims the lost income. PI that covers volunteers is the policy that would usually respond.
Illustrative example: a counselling charity. The charity uses employed and self-employed sessional counsellors. The policy needs to cover both groups, and individual counsellors may hold their own cover too. See PI for counsellors and psychotherapists.
Illustrative example: a training contract. A charity wins a council contract to deliver parenting courses. The contract requires PI at a stated limit for each claim, kept in force for several years after the contract ends. See PI for training providers.
"Our public liability covers advice." Public liability is built around injury and property damage. It does not normally respond to a claim that a client lost money because of the advice or information the charity gave them, so a charity that advises people should not rely on it for that risk.
"Cover carries on after the service ends." Not automatically. Most PI is written on a claims-made basis. If the charity closes a service and lets the policy lapse, a claim made later about advice given earlier may have no policy to respond. CC49 notes that trustees "may need to consider setting aside sufficient funds to meet the premiums for a period of several years" after advice is given. See claims-made vs occurrence and run-off cover.
Apex arranges professional indemnity and trustee indemnity insurance for charities; a broker reads every enquiry.
See also: Professional indemnity for advice charities · Free second opinion on your charity's insurance
Not always. It is usually needed if the charity gives advice, counselling, training or other professional services, or if a funder or contract requires it. Charity Commission guidance says charities providing professional advice or services should consider insurance because the charity may be liable if the service is negligent.
No. Trustee indemnity insurance protects trustees personally against claims about how they ran the charity. Professional indemnity protects the charity against claims that its advice or services were negligent. Many charities need both, and some policies combine them in separate sections with separate limits.
Usually yes. Many governing documents allow it, and section 189 of the Charities Act 2011 gives a general power where trustees decide it is in the charity's best interests. The policy must exclude certain liabilities, such as criminal fines and liabilities arising from fraud or dishonesty.
It can, but check the wording. Some policies define insured persons to include volunteers and sessional workers, while others cover only employees. A charity that relies on volunteers for advice or support work should make sure they are named or clearly included.
Commissioners commonly require PI so that if the charity's service causes a client loss, there is insurance to meet the claim. The contract usually sets a limit and may require cover to continue for a period after the contract ends, so check both before signing.
Tell us what your business does, your turnover and any claims. A broker reads every enquiry and comes back with options. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Get a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information, not advice on your individual circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.