FCA authorised · FRN 724952 0117 325 0027Goods in transit: buy onlineQuote & buy →
Apex Insurance Brokers
Speak to a brokerGet a quote →

Aipedia: Barristers

Does BMIF cover barristers' AI mistakes?

A negligence claim arising from a barrister's AI-assisted work is usually covered by BMIF in the same way as any other claim, because the BSB minimum terms allow no AI exclusion. The gaps lie in fines, aggregation, top-up layers and first-party cyber costs.

In short

Self-employed barristers must insure with BMIF on the BSB's Minimum Terms of Cover, in force since 1 July 2019. These require at least £500,000 each and every claim, defence costs in addition, and permit only a closed list of exclusions, none of which mentions AI or technology. In Apex's reading, an AI exclusion is therefore not available in the compulsory layer, though top-up insurers buying on the open market could add one. Related AI errors from one cause may aggregate into a single claim. BSB fines and disciplinary costs are excluded, and wasted costs depend on the wording.

Who must have BMIF cover

The BSB's PI page says anyone with a self-employed practising certificate must be a member of BMIF and pay premiums promptly. The only exception is a waiver for barristers practising solely in another jurisdiction and fully insured there, and the BSB cross-checks its records against BMIF's. BSB entities have separate minimum terms. Our guide to barristers' PI and the BSB covers the regime in general.

What the minimum terms require

TermRequirementRelevance to AI errors
Limit (cl.2.1)At least £500,000 each and every claim; no aggregate statedEach separate AI-related claim has its own limit
Related claims (cl.2.1)Claims from the same act, series or originating cause may be one claimRepeated AI errors may share one limit
Defence costs (cl.2.1(ii), cl.2.2)In addition, without limit, subject to proportionate reduction where a claim exceeds the limitDefending an AI-related claim does not erode the limit
Deductible (cl.2.7)As set in the cover noteApplies to AI-related claims as to others
Exclusions (cl.3.1, cl.2.4)Closed listNothing on AI or technology

Source: BSB Minimum Terms of Cover for the Self-Employed Bar.

The permitted exclusions

The closed list covers bodily injury and property damage (with carve-backs), dishonesty, other insurance, employer and occupier liability, trading debts, radioactive contamination, chambers disputes, directors' and officers' liability, contractual liability beyond the law, unauthorised jurisdictions, criminal offences and HMRC enquiries, disciplinary costs and non-reserved conveyancing, plus US and Canadian punitive damages, unconsented costs, Legal Ombudsman fee-reduction awards and BSB or regulator fines. None refers to AI. So a client claim that counsel negligently relied on a false authority or a flawed AI summary is, in principle, an ordinary claim. A BSB fine for the same conduct is not covered.

Wasted costs and aggregation

A wasted costs order is compensatory, not a regulatory fine, so it is not caught by the fines exclusion; whether a BMIF policy actually responds is a wording question we have not been able to verify. See wasted costs orders and PI.

Aggregation cuts both ways. If counsel uses the same flawed prompt or template across many advices and several clients claim, the claims may be treated as one, sharing a single £500,000 limit but possibly also a single deductible. See aggregation of claims explained.

Top-up cover and cyber

Some barristers buy top-up or excess cover above the BMIF layer on the open market. Those policies are not bound by the minimum terms, so an AI exclusion, an AI questionnaire or narrower wording could appear there. We have not seen a BSB, Bar Council or BMIF statement on AI and PI. The BSB's PI page also says the minimum terms cover third-party loss, for example from a cyber incident, but do not require first-party cyber cover. See top-up PI cover and does PI cover AI mistakes.

What can go wrong

Illustrative: a barrister uses one AI-generated template note on a statutory test in advices for several clients. The note misstates the test. Three clients bring claims. The insurer treats them as arising from one originating cause, so they share a single limit; one claim is large enough to reach the top-up layer, whose wording has an exclusion the barrister had not noticed.

What to document

More in AI use and your PI: what to document and on the AI at the Bar hub. Related: AI and written advice, free AI tools and confidentiality.

How Apex helps

Apex arranges PI for barristers. A broker can review your top-up wording for AI exclusions or questions and check how it sits above the BMIF layer.

Sources

Frequently asked

Can BMIF exclude AI-related claims?

Not within the compulsory layer, in Apex's reading. The BSB minimum terms list the exclusions that are permitted, and none of them refers to AI or technology. Top-up cover bought on the open market is not bound by those terms and could include one.

Are BSB fines for AI misuse covered?

No. BSB and other regulator fines are a permitted exclusion under the minimum terms, and so are disciplinary costs. A client's negligence claim arising from the same facts is treated separately and is usually covered, subject to the terms.

Could several AI errors count as one claim?

Possibly. The minimum terms allow related claims from the same act, series or originating cause to be treated as one claim. Repeated use of a flawed template or prompt could be argued to be one originating cause, sharing one limit.

Does BMIF cover a data breach from an AI tool?

The minimum terms cover third-party loss, which can include claims from a cyber incident, but do not require first-party cyber cover. Breach response, forensic and notification costs may need a separate cyber policy.

Check your PI covers how you use AI

Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.

Start a PI quote Request a callback

Apex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.