Aipedia: Claims management companies
CMCs can use AI to write adverts and score leads, but they remain responsible for misleading promotions, including those run by lead generators. Lead generators and consumer data are now within the FCA claims management market study.
Part of: AI in Claims management companies
In short
AI makes it easy to produce many claims adverts, landing pages and lead scores at once, often through third-party lead generators. The FCA market study launched in May 2026 covers lead generators and the acquisition, use and sale of consumer data. Under the Consumer Duty, ads that overstate outcomes or hide fees risk breaching good faith and foreseeable harm duties, and the FCA says firms remain responsible for outsourced AI. Regulatory action over adverts, including fines and refunds, usually sits outside PI cover.
Lead generation is one place CMCs may use AI. Generative tools write social media adverts, search ads and landing page copy in many variations; image and video tools create creative assets; and scoring models rank leads by likely claim value. Some firms run this in-house, but many buy leads from lead generators who use the same tools. The result is more content, produced faster, with less human review of each claim it makes to consumers.
Lead scoring raises its own questions. A model trained on past settlements may push the firm towards consumers with the largest likely payouts and away from people with smaller but valid claims, or may pick up signals linked to age, disability or financial difficulty. Those patterns are hard to see without testing, and the FCA's good-practice page expects firms to test outcomes across different consumer characteristics.
The FCA's Market Study Notice on claims management services (19 May 2026) expressly includes lead generators, including those acquiring, using or selling consumer data. The notice does not mention AI, but the activities it covers are now largely automated. The report is due by 18 May 2027, and the FCA may consider a reference to the Competition and Markets Authority. Firms buying leads should assume their supply chain will be examined.
CMCOB contains specific financial promotion and communication rules for CMCs. Check the current FCA Handbook text or your compliance adviser before relying on any summary.
Illustrative scenario. A CMC lets an AI tool generate hundreds of ad variants for a new claim type and approves them in bulk. Some variants suggest an average payout the firm cannot evidence, and a lead generator re-uses them on its own pages without the fee wording. Complaints follow from consumers who expected more, and the FCA asks the firm to explain its approval process and how it monitors third-party promotions.
The same tools can also target consumers who show signs of vulnerability, which raises further Consumer Duty questions.
PI responds to claims by third parties for losses caused by negligent professional services. Regulatory action over misleading promotions, such as fines, requirements to withdraw adverts, redress or refunds, is not usually a PI loss. Fines are commonly excluded and may be uninsurable as a matter of public policy, as our page on whether AI regulatory fines are insurable and the fines and penalties exclusion explain. Some policies offer limited cover for regulatory investigation costs, subject to the terms. A claim alleging copyright or similar rights infringement in AI-generated creative is a separate risk that may or may not fall within a PI wording.
Apex arranges PI for claims management companies and can explain how your policy treats regulatory investigations and promotion-related complaints. See AI in claims management and FCA AI rules for claims firms.
Yes. The May 2026 Market Study Notice covers lead generators, including those acquiring, using or selling consumer data, alongside professional representatives. The notice does not mention AI, but AI-driven lead generation is part of the activity under review.
In practice, yes. The FCA says firms remain responsible for consumer outcomes from AI, including outsourced AI services. If a third party promotes your service with misleading AI-generated content, expect the regulator to ask how you approved and monitored it.
Ask which AI tools produce its adverts, scripts and scores, who approves the content, where its consumer data comes from and on what consent, and whether it will share every creative and complaint. Put the answers and your monitoring rights in the contract and keep records of your checks.
Usually not. Fines are commonly excluded from PI and may be uninsurable. PI is aimed at civil claims for negligent services. Some policies pay limited investigation costs, depending on the wording.
Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Start a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.