Aipedia: Conveyancers and property lawyers
Conveyancers can use AI to summarise search results, but they must still identify and explain every adverse entry to the buyer and, where instructed, the lender. A summary that drops one entry can become a negligence claim when the buyer later finds the issue.
Part of: AI in Conveyancers and property lawyers
In short
Local authority, drainage and water, environmental and flood search reports are long and repetitive, so AI summaries are attractive. The danger is a summary that omits an adverse entry, such as a planning enforcement notice or a flood risk rating, or treats it as routine. The conveyancer must still explain material results to the buyer and report to the lender in line with its instructions. If the buyer later discovers a planning or flood problem, the claim usually falls under the firm’s PI, subject to the policy terms, and the file will be judged on what was checked.
Search reports arrive as long PDFs with a mix of standard answers, maps and risk ratings. AI tools can extract the answers that are not routine, compare them with the client's plans and produce a buyer-friendly summary. Some case management systems now generate the search section of the report on title automatically.
This works well for the routine bulk. The difficulty is that the entries that matter are often the ones phrased in a non-standard way: a planning condition attached to an old permission, a building regulation completion certificate that was never issued, a public sewer within the boundary, or a flood rating that sits just inside a higher band.
The conveyancer has to understand the results and explain what matters to the client in terms they can act on. The CLC's AI and Technology Guidance asks practices to test tools on edge cases and plan for unreliable outputs (Principle 3), to keep human review and verify outputs (Principle 9) and to make sure staff know the limits of the tool (Principle 11).
Solicitor conveyancers are subject to the SRA Misuse of AI warning notice and to Code 3.2 (competent service) and 3.5 (supervision). Where the firm also acts for the lender, the lender's instructions decide what has to be reported, and that is a separate duty from advising the buyer. See AI in new-build and lender reporting.
Illustrative scenario: a firm's AI tool summarises a local authority search as showing "no adverse planning entries". In fact the search lists an enforcement notice relating to a rear extension built by a previous owner, worded in a way the tool classified as historic. The buyer completes. Some time later the council pursues the matter, and the buyer faces the cost of regularising or removing the extension, plus a reduced value on resale.
A flood equivalent is just as plausible: the environmental report rates surface water risk as elevated, the AI summary records only river and sea risk as low, and the buyer later struggles to obtain buildings insurance after a flood. In both cases the question is whether a reasonably competent conveyancer would have spotted and explained the entry. The use of AI is not a defence.
A claim that the firm failed to report or explain a search result is a standard negligence claim. Neither the CLC Minimum Terms nor the SRA Minimum Terms mention AI, so the claim is usually dealt with in the ordinary way, subject to the excess and policy terms. CLC practices must hold at least £2m for each and every claim.
Insurers will want the search report, the AI summary, the report to the client and any evidence of review. Where the buyer's loss is the cost of a planning or flood problem rather than a full loss of value, quantum disputes are common. If the firm becomes aware of a likely claim, notify promptly: see circumstance notifications explained.
Apex arranges PI for conveyancing practices and can explain how your policy treats AI-assisted search review. See AI in conveyancing, AI-drafted reports on title and conveyancing PI premiums.
You can, if a qualified person has checked it against the original search reports and it accurately explains anything material. The summary is your advice, so errors in it are treated as your errors, not the tool's.
Usually, if it amounts to negligent advice and falls within the policy terms. Conveyancing PI exists for this type of claim. The insurer will look at what the search said, what the firm reported and whether a reasonable conveyancer would have flagged it.
No. The tool can sort and highlight, but deciding what matters for this buyer and this property is a professional judgement. The CLC explainability Principle expects practices to understand how outputs are reached, which is difficult if the tool decides materiality alone.
Do not admit liability or offer settlement without your insurer's consent. Gather the search, the AI output and your report to the client, then tell your broker so the matter can be notified under the policy if appropriate.
Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Start a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.