Aipedia: Mortgage brokers
A broker that automates rate-expiry alerts and product transfer journeys is responsible for what those systems promise and what they miss. Retention can be a large share of a broker's business, so a fault can affect hundreds of clients at once.
Part of: AI in Mortgage brokers
In short
Brokers use automated alerts to contact clients before their deal ends, and AI-driven journeys to compare a product transfer with a remortgage and steer the client to an option. PS25/11 (in force 22 July 2025) made remortgaging with a new lender and discussing options without full advice easier. The risks are alerts that fail to send, journeys that default to the existing lender when a switch would be better, and clients who drift onto a reversion rate. The FCA's 2026 good practice review flags inflexible automated journeys. Whether PI covers an automated administration failure depends on the policy wording.
A CRM holds each client's deal end date and sends alerts months in advance. More advanced systems pull current product transfer rates from the existing lender, compare them with the market, and send the client a recommendation or a link to accept an offer. Some use AI to prioritise which clients an adviser should call, based on predicted likelihood of leaving. The journey may be advised, or may use the more flexible routes in PS25/11.
Prioritisation itself carries risk. If the model ranks clients by expected value to the firm, lower-value clients, who may include those with smaller loans or more complex needs, can receive less attention. Under the Consumer Duty, outcomes should be monitored across different groups of customers rather than only in aggregate.
PS25/11, published and in force on 22 July 2025, made it easier to discuss options with customers without triggering full advice, to remortgage with a new lender and to reduce mortgage terms. The FCA said the amended rules give "greater opportunity for innovation". It contains no AI content, but the lighter-touch journeys it enables are the ones brokers are most likely to automate. The Consumer Duty still applies to them.
Illustrative scenario: a broker migrates to a new CRM. Deal end dates import correctly for most clients, but cases completed through one lender import with a blank field, so no alerts are sent. Months later, several clients realise they have been on the lender's reversion rate since their fix ended. They complain that the broker promised to contact them before expiry. The fault affects every client in that group.
Other problems include a journey that only shows the existing lender's products, a recommendation engine that ignores early repayment charges or a planned move, and an alert sent to an old email address that nobody checks.
This depends on two questions. First, did the broker owe a duty to contact the client? That usually turns on what the firm promised in its terms of business and marketing. Second, does the policy treat the failure as part of the firm's professional services? Some mortgage PI wordings may cover breach of duty in the conduct of the firm's regulated business, which may include administration, but definitions vary. A policy meeting MIPRU 3.2.4R must cover Ombudsman awards.
A single system fault affecting many clients also raises aggregation: whether the claims count as one, with one excess, or many. See aggregation of claims in PI.
Apex arranges PI for mortgage brokers and can check how your wording treats administration errors and aggregated claims from one system fault. More guides are on the mortgage broker AI hub.
It depends on what the broker promised. If the terms of business or marketing said the firm would contact the client before expiry, a failure may be a breach. If no promise was made, the position is less clear and depends on the facts.
No. PS25/11 simplified some mortgage rules, including making it easier to remortgage with a new lender and to discuss options without full advice. It contains no AI content, though the FCA said the changes give greater opportunity for innovation.
It depends on the aggregation clause in the policy. Some wordings treat claims arising from the same originating cause as one claim, others are narrower. The answer affects how many excesses apply and how much of the limit is used.
Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Start a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.