Aipedia: Patent and trade mark attorneys
AI can speed up freedom-to-operate searches and claim mapping, but an FTO opinion is only as good as the search behind it and the caveats around it. Clients use FTO advice to make launch decisions, so a missed patent can lead to very large losses.
Part of: AI in patent and trade mark attorneys
In short
Attorneys use AI to search for in-force patents, map claims against a product and draft infringement analysis. Clients then launch, invest or license on the strength of the opinion. The main gap is between what the AI search covered and what the opinion appears to say. IPReg's AI guidance relies on existing duties of competence and clear client information. If a client is sued for infringement after a clean opinion, its claim against the attorney may include damages, costs and lost investment. PI usually responds subject to the policy terms, but the limit may be tested.
Freedom-to-operate work asks whether a product or process can be launched in a territory without infringing others' in-force rights. AI tools help search for relevant patents, filter by legal status, map claim elements against product features and draft the analysis. CITMA's 2025 report notes AI automating searching and stresses human review.
FTO differs from patentability searching because the stakes rest on what was not found. A legal status error, a missed family member or a pending application that later grants can each defeat the conclusion.
Clients may want FTO advice quickly and cheaply, close to a launch date, and AI makes a fast answer possible. That pressure makes it tempting to narrow the search or the review without making the narrowing visible in the opinion. When time or budget limits the work, the opinion should say so, and the client should decide whether to accept that risk. A short, clearly limited opinion is easier to defend than a confident one that overstates its basis.
A key weakness can be not a bad search but an opinion that implies more than the search supports. A two-page conclusion that "no blocking patents were identified" reads as comfort, even if the search was limited to one database, excluded applications and covered only part of the product. Scope caveats need to be specific, prominent and repeated where the conclusion appears, and the engagement letter should match them.
Illustrative scenario: a firm gives an FTO opinion for a device launch based on an AI search and AI claim mapping. A granted patent is missed because the tool's legal status data showed it as lapsed when it had been restored. The client launches, is sued, settles and claims its damages, legal costs and wasted launch spend from the firm, saying the opinion gave no warning of status risk.
A negligent FTO claim would usually fall within IPReg-compliant PI, subject to the policy terms. These claims can be large because they track the client's infringement exposure and business losses. The minimum terms set a floor, not a ceiling, and attorneys doing FTO for larger clients may consider top-up cover. Check how the aggregation clause would treat related opinions on the same product. Note that this is a claim against the attorney for negligent advice, which differs from a claim that your own firm infringed IP; see does PI cover IP infringement.
Apex arranges PI and top-up cover for patent attorneys, and a broker can help you consider limits for FTO work. See the attorneys hub, AI prior art searching and AI portfolio analytics.
It can use one, but the opinion must reflect what was actually searched and its limits. Legal status should be checked at source, and claim construction remains a legal judgment for the attorney, not the tool.
Because clients rely on FTO advice to launch products, invest or license. If a missed patent leads to infringement proceedings, the client's claim may include damages, legal costs and wasted launch spending. That can exceed the minimum limits.
There is no specific IPReg rule requiring it, but the guidance relies on clear client information. Explaining the tools, data sources and their limits helps the client understand the residual risk, and gives you a record of what the client was told.
It depends on your limit, any top-up layers and the aggregation clause. IPReg's minimum terms are a floor. Firms advising on high-value launches should review limits with a broker, subject to what insurers will offer.
Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Start a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.