Aipedia: Patent and trade mark attorneys
In Emotional Perception [2026] UKSC 3 the Supreme Court departed from the Aerotel test and adopted the EPO's G1/19 "any hardware" approach to excluded subject matter. Advice on patenting AI that relied on the old test may now be wrong.
Part of: AI in patent and trade mark attorneys
In short
On 11 February 2026 the Supreme Court decided Emotional Perception AI Ltd v Comptroller-General. It departed from the Aerotel four-step test and adopted the EPO's G1/19 "any hardware" approach, without adopting the Comvik method wholesale. It held that an artificial neural network is a program for a computer, but the claims, which involved hardware, were not excluded "as such". The UKIPO was wrong to refuse, and the case is likely remitted for novelty and inventive step. Attorneys should review drafting and prosecution advice on AI inventions, as outdated advice could support a negligence claim.
Emotional Perception AI Ltd v Comptroller-General [2026] UKSC 3 concerned a patent application for an invention using an artificial neural network, which the UKIPO had refused as excluded subject matter. The key points of the judgment are:
For AI inventions, the exclusion hurdle has moved. Under Aerotel, the excluded subject matter stage was where this application failed at the UKIPO. After Emotional Perception, claims involving hardware pass that hurdle, and the argument moves to novelty and inventive step. How the UK will assess inventive step for such claims, and how UKIPO practice will change, is still being worked out, and the remitted application is one to watch.
Practical effects for attorneys include:
A competent attorney is expected to keep up with significant changes in the law. Advice given after 11 February 2026 that still applies Aerotel to exclusion, without noting the change, is at risk. Advice given before that date is judged by the law at the time, but a firm that has active matters affected by the change may need to tell clients.
AI research tools add a specific risk: a tool trained on older material may still describe Aerotel as the current UK test. That is exactly the kind of output that needs checking against the judgment itself.
Illustrative scenario: in spring 2026 a firm advises a client to abandon a UK application for a machine learning invention, relying on an AI-generated research note summarising the Aerotel approach. A competitor later obtains UK protection for a similar system. The client says the firm should have known of Emotional Perception and that the abandoned application had good prospects.
A claim that advice applied the wrong legal test would usually fall within IPReg-compliant PI as negligence, subject to the policy terms. These claims may be hard to value because the client must show what the application would have achieved. Time limits for such claims can run from when the client knew of the damage; see limitation for professional negligence. If a review of your files reveals advice that may have caused loss, consider whether to notify a circumstance.
Apex arranges PI for patent attorneys, and a broker can help you consider notification if a file review reveals advice affected by the change. See the attorneys hub, advising on AI-generated inventions and AI patent drafting.
No. In Emotional Perception [2026] UKSC 3 the Supreme Court departed from the Aerotel four-step test and adopted the EPO's G1/19 any hardware approach for excluded subject matter, without adopting the Comvik method wholesale.
They are not excluded as such where the claims involve hardware, but they must still be new and inventive. How UKIPO practice on inventive step develops after the decision is still being worked out.
Reviewing live matters is sensible: pending applications, ongoing prosecution and recent advice not to file. Tell affected clients about the change and record what you advised. If a review reveals possible loss, consider whether to notify your PI insurer.
Advice is judged by the law at the time it was given. But advice given after 11 February 2026 that ignores the change is at risk, and firms with affected live matters may need to update clients. Such claims would usually fall under PI, subject to the policy terms.
Tell us about your firm and the work you do. A broker will review how your current PI treats AI-assisted work, or arrange new cover. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.
Start a PI quote Request a callbackApex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information about how AI is used in the profession and how insurance may respond. It is not legal, regulatory or insurance advice on your circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.