FCA authorised · FRN 724952 0117 325 0027Goods in transit: buy onlineQuote & buy →
Apex Insurance Brokers
Speak to a brokerGet a quote →

Insurance explained

Does trustee indemnity cover Charity Commission inquiries?

Trustee indemnity insurance is cover that protects charity trustees personally against claims for breach of trust or duty, and many policies also pay legal costs in regulatory investigations. It matters because a Charity Commission inquiry can run for months, and trustees often need their own legal advice throughout.

In short

Trustee indemnity insurance often pays trustees' legal and representation costs when the Charity Commission investigates, including a statutory inquiry under section 46 of the Charities Act 2011, but only where the policy wording includes investigation costs and the trigger is met. It does not pay fines or regulatory penalties, or criminal defence costs where a trustee is convicted of fraud, dishonesty or wilful or reckless misconduct, because section 189 requires those exclusions. Early notification of circumstances, such as a serious incident report or a letter from the Commission, is usually the step that decides whether cover responds.

How Charity Commission investigations work

The Charity Commission has a general power under section 46 of the Charities Act 2011 to institute inquiries into charities, a particular charity or a class of charities. It can run an inquiry itself or appoint someone to conduct it and report back.

Not every concern becomes a statutory inquiry. The Commission's guidance on statutory inquiries (CC46) explains that it may carry out a pre-investigation first and, where the criteria for an inquiry are not met, may instead give regulatory advice and guidance to the trustees. Once an inquiry is open, certain legal powers become available, including:

The guidance says it is the Commission's normal practice to issue a public statement when an inquiry opens and to report publicly on its findings, usually within three months of the substantive investigation ending. Many inquiries begin with a serious incident report; our charity serious incident statistics show the volume and main categories.

What trustee indemnity usually pays, and what it does not

Trustee indemnity insurance was designed around civil claims for breach of trust or duty, but most modern wordings, often sold as charity D&O or management liability, add cover for investigation costs. Whether a particular inquiry is covered depends on the definitions and limits in your policy.

Cost or lossUsual positionPoints to check
Solicitor's fees to advise trustees once an inquiry opensCommonly covered as investigation or defence costs, subject to the policy termsWhether an informal enquiry counts or only a formal inquiry
Preparing for interviews and responding to section 47 directionsOften covered for the individual trusteeInsurer consent to the choice of solicitor and hourly rates
Civil claims for breach of trust that follow an inquiryThe core cover of the policyLimit, excess and any claims by the charity itself
Fines in criminal proceedings and regulatory penaltiesNot coveredExcluded by section 189(2) of the Charities Act 2011
Criminal defence costs where convicted of fraud, dishonesty or wilful or reckless misconductNot covered once the conviction is finalSome wordings advance costs and claw them back
The charity's own costs, such as an interim managerUsually not under the trustee coverWhether there is separate entity cover

Investigation cover is sometimes subject to a sublimit within the overall limit, and some policies pay only after a formal step such as written notice from the regulator. See D&O defence costs and investigations cover for how these extensions are typically structured.

The statutory exclusions you cannot buy back

Where trustees use charity funds to buy the cover, section 189 of the Charities Act 2011 requires the policy to exclude certain things. The Commission's Charities and insurance guidance (CC49) summarises them as:

Section 189 also says trustees may buy the cover only if they decide it is in the charity's best interests, applying the statutory duty of care. The full list of contractual exclusions insurers add on top is covered in trustee indemnity insurance exclusions.

Who needs to think about this: illustrative examples

The examples below are illustrative only and do not describe real charities or claims.

Illustrative example 1: a safeguarding concern. A youth charity reports a serious incident. The Commission opens an inquiry and directs the trustees to produce minutes and attend interviews. A policy with investigation cover would commonly fund each trustee's legal representation, subject to the insurer's consent and any sublimit.

Illustrative example 2: financial controls. Funds go missing at a grant-making charity. The inquiry questions whether trustees exercised proper oversight. Cover may pay representation costs for the honest trustees, while any trustee found to have acted dishonestly would usually lose cover under the conduct exclusion and severability provisions.

Illustrative example 3: a board dispute. A split between trustees leads to complaints and a regulatory review. Claims brought by one trustee against another may fall within an insured versus insured exclusion, so the wording matters.

Charitable companies, CIOs and larger unincorporated charities all face this exposure. D&O insurance for charities explains how the cover fits different structures.

A common misunderstanding: an inquiry is not always a claim

Many trustees assume any contact from the Commission is automatically covered. In practice, older or basic wordings define a claim as a written demand for compensation or civil proceedings, which a regulatory inquiry is not. Newer wordings commonly widen the definition to include formal investigations, and sometimes informal enquiries or interviews.

The other key point is notification. A serious incident report, a whistleblowing complaint or a first letter from the Commission may not yet be a claim, but it is very often a circumstance that could give rise to one. Most trustee indemnity policies are written on a claims-made basis, so notifying that circumstance during the current period can secure cover under that policy even if the inquiry or claim arrives later. Failing to do so can leave a gap at renewal, because the next insurer will usually exclude known circumstances. Our guide to circumstance notification covers the mechanics, which work the same way here. The difference between this cover and professional indemnity is set out in charity trustee PI versus trustee indemnity.

What to check before buying or renewing

For a wider view of charity cover, see the charity insurance broker guide. Apex arranges trustee indemnity and charity D&O cover; a broker reads every enquiry.

Sources

Frequently asked

Will trustee indemnity insurance pay my legal fees if the Charity Commission opens an inquiry?

Often, yes, if your policy includes investigation or regulatory costs cover and the inquiry meets the policy definition. Many modern wordings pay reasonable legal costs for trustees once a formal investigation starts, usually with the insurer's prior consent and sometimes within a sublimit. Older or basic policies that only respond to civil claims may not pay, so check the definition of claim.

Can insurance pay a fine or penalty imposed on a charity trustee?

No, where the cover is bought with charity funds. Section 189 of the Charities Act 2011 requires the policy to exclude fines imposed in criminal proceedings and sums payable to a regulatory authority as a penalty for non-compliance. Defence costs may still be covered up to that point, subject to the policy terms.

Should we tell our insurer about a serious incident report?

Usually it is sensible to discuss it with your broker promptly. A serious incident report is not normally a claim, but it may be a circumstance that could lead to one. Notifying it during the current claims-made policy period can secure cover under that policy if an inquiry or claim follows later.

Does the cover protect the charity itself during an inquiry?

Trustee indemnity insurance protects the individual trustees, not the charity. The charity's own costs, such as an interim manager appointed by the Commission or the cost of its own response, are usually outside the trustee cover unless the policy includes separate entity cover.

Are honest trustees still covered if another trustee acted dishonestly?

Usually, if the policy has a severability or non-imputation clause. These clauses commonly mean the knowledge or conduct of one trustee is not attributed to the others, so innocent trustees keep their cover while the dishonest trustee loses it after a final finding. Check the exact wording.

Talk to a broker about this cover

Tell us what your business does, your turnover and any claims. A broker reads every enquiry and comes back with options. No fee for a quote. Or call 0117 325 0027.

Start a commercial enquiry Request a callback

Apex Insurance Brokers Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered in England and Wales, company number 07014570. This page is general information, not advice on your individual circumstances, and it does not guarantee that cover will be available or on what terms.